.png)
.png)
Platform
Living in Buffalo, Wyoming
Buffalo, Wyoming is a historic Western town at the base of the Bighorn Mountains, known for its walkable downtown, strong outdoor recreation, and authentic small-town character. As the county seat of Johnson County, Buffalo serves as both a year-round residential community and a regional hub for services, culture, and history. Its location along a major travel corridor between Mount Rushmore and Yellowstone National Park makes it a gateway community for visitors, while still offering a grounded, livable lifestyle for full-time residents. The Buffalo real estate market typically centers in the high-$300,000s to mid-$400,000s, attracting buyers seeking affordability, Western heritage, and access to public lands.
If Buffalo, Wyoming were a person, it would be the Friendly History Buff Who Owns the Feed Store. Big handshake energy. Knows every trailhead, every back road, and every story worth telling. Proud of its Western roots, Buffalo blends frontier history with everyday warmth — the kind of town where people still stop to talk, lend a truck when needed, and pass down stories along with traditions. There’s a deep sense of continuity here, where history isn’t staged for tourists but lived and respected by the people who call Buffalo home.
Considering a move? Download my Free Relocation Guide
Why Live in Buffalo?
Buffalo sits where the rolling plains meet the Bighorn Mountains, giving residents quick access to Bighorn National Forest, Clear Creek, and Highway 16—the scenic “Cloud Peak Skyway” into high‑country lakes, trails, and campgrounds. The town offers a classic Western main street, historic hotels, and local restaurants while maintaining a relaxed pace compared with larger Rocky Mountain resort towns.
Daily life is supported by a full complement of small‑city services, including grocery stores, medical offices, schools, a public library, recreation facilities, and numerous parks along Clear Creek. Residents appreciate the tight‑knit community, easy access to outdoor recreation, and the ability to live in a smaller market while still having I‑25 and I‑90 connectivity to Casper, Sheridan, and beyond.
Buffalo, Wyoming at a Glance
Buffalo is the county seat of Johnson County with an estimated 2025 population around 4,700 residents, up roughly 6% from the 2020 census count of 4,427. The city covers about 4.5 square miles, has a population density near 1,000 people per square mile, and serves as the primary service center for surrounding ranching areas.
Demographically, Buffalo is about 94% White, with small percentages of residents identifying as Native American, Asian, “other race,” or two or more races. Median household income is in the low‑ to mid‑$60,000s, with average household income around the high‑$60,000s to low‑$70,000s and a poverty rate near 12%, reflecting a mixed retiree and working‑family base.
Key amenities and points of interest include:
Clear Creek and the Clear Creek Trail System, which wind through town and City Park, offering walking, biking, fishing, and picnic space.
Buffalo City Park with playgrounds, tennis and pickleball courts, horseshoe pits, skatepark, and shaded creekside areas.
Easy access to Bighorn National Forest, Meadowlark Lake, and Cloud Peak Wilderness for camping, hiking, hunting, and winter sports.
The community also features a public library (through Johnson County Library), local museums and historic sites, and a network of churches and civic groups that host meetings and events throughout the year. Public education is provided by Johnson County School District #1, with in‑town elementary, middle, and high schools serving Buffalo and surrounding rural areas.
Buffalo, WY: Recent and Annual Events
Buffalo’s events calendar combines Western heritage, live music, and community festivals centered on summer tourism and local traditions. Seasonal highlights and recurring events include:
Car shows and classic‑car gatherings in City Park, often promoted as free or low‑cost weekend events.
“Lovin’ Junkin’” antique and vintage shows at Bomber Mountain Civic Center, along with other craft and vendor fairs.
Travel and tourism sources also feature:
Guided and self‑guided history experiences around downtown’s historic hotels, Bozeman Trail sites, and Mountain Plains Heritage Park walking trail.
Year‑round outdoor activities such as Clear Creek Trail walks, fishing, mountain biking, cross‑country skiing, and snowmobiling just outside town in Bighorn National Forest.
Buffalo routinely participates in regional rodeos, holiday parades, and county‑fair activities, with many larger‑scale Western events coordinated across Johnson County and nearby communities.
Real Estate in Buffalo, Wyoming
Zillow’s home value index places the typical home value in Buffalo around $397,800 as of late 2025, up about 3.3% over the prior year. That same data set shows a recent median sale price near $363,000 and a median list price just under $385,000 in late 2025, indicating modest appreciation with a relatively affordable entry point compared with many mountain‑adjacent towns.
Other sources highlight the variability in this small market:
Redfin reports a recent median sale price around $360,000, up roughly 20% year over year in its latest monthly snapshot, with homes spending about 70 days on market.
Movoto shows a November 2025 median sale price of about $462,500, with an average days on market around 132, reflecting the influence of higher‑end sales and small sample sizes.
Realtor.com data for the Buffalo area notes a median list (for‑sale) price around $370,000 with a relatively large surrounding inventory, likely reflecting a broader search area beyond city limits.
Taken together, Buffalo’s residential market generally clusters:
Typical/average values: high‑$300,000s.
Recent medians: mid‑$300,000s to mid‑$400,000s depending on the month and data source.
Product types range from in‑town historic homes and bungalows near downtown to newer subdivisions on the edges of town, rural acreages, and ranchettes in the surrounding county. Market conditions are “somewhat competitive,” with most homes eventually selling but days on market stretching longer than in Wyoming’s hottest small towns.
Ready to check out real estate in Buffalo and surrounding areas?
Is Buffalo Right for You?
Buffalo is a strong match if you want a small Western town with a real downtown, good access to public lands, and home prices that are generally lower than many other Bighorn‑adjacent markets while still offering essential services. Residents who value fishing, hiking, and mountain day trips, plus a quieter lifestyle and community events in the park, tend to find Buffalo’s setting very appealing.
On the other hand, Buffalo may feel limited if you require major‑city shopping, large hospitals, or a broad nightlife scene, as services are small‑city scale and the nearest larger markets are Sheridan and Casper. Relocating from a large city like Denver can create a culture shock. When I moved from Denver to Ranchester, the pace adjustment was refreshing and the shock was temporary - so don't worry. The housing market is relatively small and can be volatile month‑to‑month, so buyers should expect fluctuating medians, longer days on market in some price bands, and the need to monitor both in‑town and nearby rural listings to find the right fit.
If you're ready to learn more about the Buffalo community, grab a spot on my calendar and let's chat.
Nearby Communities to Consider
Many buyers compare Buffalo, WY with nearby towns depending on lifestyle priorities.
You may also want to explore:
Living in Sheridan, Wyoming – more amenities, culture, and services
Living in Dayton, Wyoming – mountain proximity and creative energy
Living in Ranchester, Wyoming – the handy, nearby neighbor to Sheridan
Thinking About Moving to Buffalo?
Whether you’re relocating from out of state, downsizing into something simpler, or searching for land and breathing room near Sheridan, I’m here to help you explore your options with clarity and local insight.
📥 Download Your Free Sheridan Area Relocation Guide
📞 Schedule a Home Buying Consultation
📈 Curious About Your Home’s Value?